Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Geer's avatar

keep gerrymandering?

Expand full comment
DR Darke's avatar

I admit that CrowdStrike going down reminded me, with a shiver, of the BATTLESTAR GALACTICA reboot, and how all the newer ships that were networked together became sitting ducks when their security was breached en masse. Only the GALACTICA, an obsolete Battlestar deemed unfit to be part of the network, was able to fight back because its security wasn't compromised....

We're already starting to see how cyberwarfare can be used, thanks to Russia and the Ukraine using it against each other to shut down vital systems like military hardware, electricity, water treatment, even traffic lights. We've been watching for a while how governments will pay (or order) software companies not to patch specific vulnerabilities so THEY can get inside—under the laughable assumption that it's some form of "golden key" that only "The Good Guys" have!

The definition of "Good Guys" very much depends on who you are, and who you want to attack. I don't doubt for a second that Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin consider themselves "Good Guys" when it comes to protecting their vision of China or Russia, just like I don't doubt the NSA considers themselves "Good Guys" when it comes to domestic espionage. Don't even get me started on how not allowing vulnerabilities to be patched, or demanding a "backdoor" to software like Congress keeps doing, assumes that nobody ELSE will figure out that "backdoor" and use it for their own purposes.

I keep wondering if maybe, just maybe, "hardening" our security shouldn't include beefing up analog versions of vital systems so they can be reset manually a lot more easily than they are now. It would also be a *mitzvah* if the U.S. were to, I don't know, not act as if we own the planet and all the people on it—but I suspect that's a miracle too far....

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts